Sunday, August 12, 2012

Tackle the bullied in you: an example set by a nine year old

http://www.cybervictims.org


  As a young student I was also subjected to bullying by my schoolmates. Unfortunately twenty –twenty five years back in India the word “bullying” was pretty unfamiliar with the students, parents, teachers and also behavioural scientists. When I joined this school in Kolkata in the late parts of 1980’s as an 8th standard student, at first, my new classmates could not happily accommodate me in their groups. They took time. In between I regularly got to hear teasing and humiliating words targeting my body structure, my previous location and even my family back ground. Teachers were of no help either as they were busy bringing out the best of the lot for the forthcoming public exams. My only comfort cushions were my parents and my sister. We felt that these were extremely humiliating and teasing words; but never knew that this particular behavior is known as bullying and it is that particular girl/s who loved hurling those remarks, who needed more attention from the teachers and counsellors than me, because she/they probably had terrible personality disorders.  My mother probably understood this and she constantly petted me, comforted me telling me that I need to be strong enough to deal with such people not only in the school, but in future also. I grew up being a person strongly advocating positive thinking. I finally understood what my former classmates were actually going through when I got this golden opportunity to work in the project on cyber bullying. Huge amount of literature made me aware of various patterns of school bullying; added with this, my mentor Jayne Hitchcock, President, Working to Halt Online Abuse (WHOA), gifted me a unique training on how to withstand cyber bullying. No wonder, physical bullying and cyber bullying are different in nature and the effects of both may not be the same. But the core effect of bullying, either in case of physical bullying, or in case of cyber bullying remains the same; it hurts, it destroys the self confidence of the victim and it successfully wastes huge lot of study and activity times for the young victims.
            No sooner, I saw a growing little princess in my own home, my daughter, who I felt would be more vulnerable to bullying as she comes from a mixed cultural background and has a very uncommon name for the school. Some of her early behavioural symptoms regarding her day to day interactions with her classmates made me aware that bullying is back in this generation with the same old flavour. I started experimenting with her the tricks that my mother taught me and that were further nurtured by Jayne. I made her understand that whatever some people say her, she will always remain my darling princess, I will encourage her for better performances on each of her failures and I would love to see her as whatever she aims to be. Well, a pinch of sour; I warned her that I will not be her well-wisher if she crosses her lines for bad and   she has to learn from her own mistakes then, which might be extremely painful. Over the times, she accepted me as her best friend. She shares her own thoughts with me and she teaches me as how to laugh away worries and win over the situation.
And then came the biggest surprise for me as a mom . she came back from the school last week and showed me her note ; someone has left a message for her in her note  telling “You’re Loose”... the particular ‘adjective’ is a very common one in this place to describe one as a fool, idiot and stupid. No sooner I understood that some one has become a bully and found a (wrong) target in my daughter. I looked at my daughter and asked “are you hurt?” she twisted her lips in an attempt to smile and answered “well, not really. But I want to know who is this ‘friend’?”. I told her ‘what is the use in finding that out? Better ignore and enjoy life.’ She answered “I want to show him/her something”. I was literally taken aback when she returned from her desk after a few minutes; she had written this message as you can see above in the picture to the bully. she wrote " yes, loose persons win"  and she carefully closed the message by adding her own 'signature' "from Rai".
She started giggling heavily.......... the sweetest thing every parent would love to hear from his/her child; she told me she can see a baby with a back pack, a ripe fat tomato, a drum stick and  two unequal shaped potatoes... her favourite vegetables. I felt a peculiar joy.. She successfully tackled the ‘bullied’ in her. She refused to let herself be bogged down by the message. She gave me the greatest message “the writer would feel good if I feel bad....... I am feeling happy to get so many amusing things in the note.... thank you who ever you are”.
Didn’t she just reveal a CORE feeling? Don’t let yourself feel bullied. The more you FEEL the more you are HURT.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2012), “Tackle the bullied in you: an example set by a nine year old”, 12th  August,2012, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/

Sunday, July 29, 2012

Cut-copy –paste....who cares?

http://www.cybervictims.org


Recently I met some young fresh college students who were preparing for their assignments. When they showed me the topics, I could not hold back my surprise and also appreciation. The topic was about new findings on astro-physics and they had to contribute from their own understandings. When I asked them what do they think about it, almost all of them answered that ‘internet will think for us’. Apparently they were planning to spend some days in the net- searching and then put the results of the same in the assignments. But the question is how far these contributions would be original? A faculty in a local college told me ‘no wonder, none of them write from their own’. It is no surprise to me too. Last year, I got to see one of my own write-ups on cyber crime against women, neatly cut and pasted in a scholarly article which came for submission to a noted journal. The editor somehow sensed something wrong and alerted me.
But I am not alone in this “stolen and victimised” group. There are many noted as well as upcoming scholars whose works are being used without proper citation or acknowledgements by others. Either such people do not know about copy right violations, or they care a hang about these. But what no one understands is, more than violation of certain legal terms, it victimises the original creator.  A simple blog full of genuine creativeness may take minimum two days time to materialise; whereas a full length scholarly paper may take minimum three months to maximum five months time to be written to the expectations of a standard journal. Indeed, the cost of  heavy weight books may not be afforded by many, and these open access informative write ups not only help people (especially students) to fill up the vacuum, but also they help them to finish off their works in record times. Just “search” and you would get the answers even at the odd hours of midnight. But it no way means that one can use these sources as mugging up knowledge to pour over in the assignments or projects. It is unfortunate that in India among the high school and undergraduate students, awareness regarding copy right violation in relation to such ‘references’ is hopelessly low. A striking reason for this could be that the law meant for copyright protection in India, has given much weightage  to literary, dramatic, musical works, architecture, computer programmes, films, photographs etc.  Scholarly works, which include short write-ups also, fall much in the kitty of the publisher/s  who choose to publish them. Authors of such works therefore in many cases become secondary copyright holder, or may not have the copyright at all, but confers the right to their publisher/s.   However, the same may not be the case when the write up is published in the world wide net. While independent bloggers using Google services, or independent writers using other web-pages hosted in the US, are hugely protected by the Digital Millennium Copyright Act or DMCA irrespective of their nationality, in India, the law is little tricky in this regard.   Section 3 of the Copyright Act, 1957 makes it clear that ‘publication’ means “making a work available to the public by issue of copies or communicating the work to the public”. This very definition apparently gives an indication that once a write-up is “floated” for public viewing, it is published. But the very next section, i.e, section 4 warns people that when such ‘publication’ is made without the author’s proper ‘license of the owner of the copyright’, it would be considered not published in the eyes of law. The conjugated inner meaning of these two sections lies in the fact that even if the work is ‘published’, no individual is allowed to use the same as his/her own work unless the original owner properly authorises the other person to use it. In practise, this authorisation can be implied when one uses a write-up from an open access source after properly citing the author’s name, the title of the write-up, the place where it is published and the date when it was published. However, when the write-up is published with the note from the author that it can be reused only with the written permission from the author, the way of obtaining permission extends by personally approaching the author for his/her permission.
In India hardly any undergraduate student is actually aware or is told about this. I observed that this awareness of respecting other’s hard work slowly arises in some students by regular reading of other available reading materials; some learn this when their works are rejected by editors on the ground of plagiarism. But unfortunately the number of these awakened individuals is very less. Largely, the education system is liable for this. In our schools we ask the students to produce exactly what is written in the text books; hardly any parent or teacher can spend time to make their wards understand what those scriptures actually mean. Many parents are never happy when they learn that their children are not taking up professional courses but prefer to be “thinkers”, or ‘researchers’; even when some land up in their dream courses, they are pressurised to produce some contributions towards the subject without being told how to do it on their own without ‘stealing’ other’s ideas. This gives rise to the vicious circle of infringement of copyrights and victimising the original authors.
Solution? Unless the ‘predecessors’/teachers/guides/parents show the way to be ‘innovative’, cut-copy-paste culture would happily exist in the land of unique thinkers and writers. Young students .......don’t victimise authors; respect their work, learn from them and show the world who inspired your work.
 Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2012), “Cut-copy –paste....who cares?
”, 29th July,2012, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”

 

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Misuse of information technology, digital devices and rise of cyber crimes

http://www.cybervictims.org

In India consumption of information technology and electronic mediums for the same has seen steep high since the new millennium. I remember a Tamil movie in the late 1990s which showed how the computers would be used in future; it showed people are literally throwing off their desk tops  to the dustbins since they were “over used”,  people belonging to average income group have the power to buy laptops and grass root level workers are using mobile phones. Nonetheless, I am talking about an era when a desk top computer would have costed not less than twenty thousand rupees ( nearly $400) and an ordinary mobile phone with no device other than device for speaking and hearing would have costed not less than two thousand rupees (nearly $40). Cost of internet and pre paid sim cards for mobile phones were not generally accessible by people belonging to lower to middle income group.  As such, computers and mobile phones were considered to be prized possessions for the creamy layers. India was slowly getting introduced to cyber crimes like hacking. Crimes like child pornography, phishing etc were still considered as “not our problem still now”. Things have changed since then.
            Back in 2012, couple of days ago I was sitting at the railway station waiting for my train which will connect us to the international flight to Sweden. I was online through my husband’s IPad,  searching for some last moment details about the conference we were about to attend in couple of hours. Suddenly a woman shouted at me telling “ you will not spare the computer even at the railway station? be careful.. somebody might steal it.” Stunned, I looked  at her:  the woman must be in her late twenties, in a dirty sari, neatly pinned up here and there. She was a schizophrenic; must have been abandoned by her family and she remembers clearly how the computer screen looks like when one is online.  She sat on the floor near me and from her distracted communication with her imaginary child, I could clearly understand that she was  persuading the child to not to sit with “mobile phones”.  Within an hour or so, I saw another man, a daily wage earner who commutes from nearby place, speaking loudly over his prize possession, a cell phone with camera. I remember another incidence: on my way to Kolkata couple of years back, I got a few co passengers who were contract labourers from north Indian states. A couple of stations later, a young woman boarded the same compartment. She was accompanied by a man who could be her colleague, or even her boyfriend. Both of them looked well educated and professionals. One of the earlier co passengers made good use of his mobile phone; he started clicking the camera device randomly. When the woman noticed it, she instantly demanded not to click her and the owner of the device politely told her that he is getting accustomed to the device and doesn’t know how to handle it......lame excuse indeed. The lady’s companion snatched the phone and found a few pictures of the woman in different poses. He patiently deleted all of them and warned the owner that if he again does it, he will take stern action. The woman was probably spared because the owner of the device got down in the next halt without making any more attempt to ruin the peace.
What did I learn from all these incidences? Digital technology if put in wrong hands, can be devastating.  We can divide the cyber miscreants in two different sects: one who do it for fun; one who don’t do it for fun. There are numerous examples  of sexting cases, phone bullying cases involving children where you can see the  first sect of miscreants.  In many such  US court cases, defence had established ignorance of the accused. But what about miscreants who are not minors and who intentionally mishandle it for the purpose of experimenting the devices? Basically we can do nothing. There is no law in any country which prohibits ignorant persons from possessing a digital device with information and communication technology, be it a computer, or a mobile phone.  But off course, experience can turn an ignorant into a mighty individual. I sadly note that when laymen such as the above gather experience in handling the devices, the results may not be good. My assumption may not testify all, but surely would testify some.   The devices have inbuilt mechanism and the internet always opens it doors with both good and bad shades, which allures new users to experiment. This can lead to devastating effect including hacking and sexual offences of cyber space. What these people lack actually is the knowledge of cyber etiquette. Remember the old tradition of  attaching license for possessing radio? Perhaps it is time now for the companies making computers and electronic gadgets like the cell phones to think of attaching a module of user manual including etiquettes  with their products. May be this could bring down purposeful mishandling of the devices which gives rise to various sorts of cyber crimes.
Or you need to believe..... no gain no pain...

Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2012), “Misuse of information technology, digital devices and rise of cyber crimes”, 21st June,2012, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”



Saturday, May 19, 2012

Stop people: spare the disputed Mamata Banerjee cartoon

http://www.cybervictims.org

The cartoon controversy of  West Bengal Chief minister  has  created a new focus point for cyber law researchers like me. Why wouldn’t an individual express his political ideologies through cartoons? Why would the government gag this right?  Most supporters of liberal free speech guarantee protested the  Chief  Minister’s angry protests when a professor of a reputed university had reportedly spread the cartoon through someone else’s email id. When the lady noted the issue and the man behind this was indicted by the police, he apologetically accepted his first mistake, sending message from someone else’s email id. But he failed to understand the mistake which created such a big controversy, i.e spreading a supposedly offensive cartoon about Mamata Banerjee’s administrative skill and  human resource managerial skill. The cartoon was made after the then minister Trivedi was dropped by Banerjee because of some internal tip offs between the two. It apparently depicts parts of a  conversation between the two characters of a famous detective series film made by the legendary film maker Satyajit Ray for children. The cartoon picture which was widely circulated in the Facebook, showed Mamata’s face cut and pasted along with other two ministers, where one of the individuals tells “ei sei dustu lok”, meaning this is the bad man, and mamata says “dustu lok vanish”, meaning bad man vanish. She apparently speaks similar words like the villain in the noted children’s film where the person pushes another one to death and clarifies to the child protagonist that he has made him ‘vanished’(see Professor arrested for poking fun at Mamata. HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times
Kolkata, April 13, 2012. http://www.hindustantimes.com/India-news/WestBengal/Professor-arrested-for-poking-fun-at-Mamata/Article1-839847.aspx) .
What irked mamata were using her picture for conveying this ‘bad’ image, and also using the speech which according to her, conveyed the same meaning to the audience as the film characters did.... murdering the man in question  and removing him  from her path. According to the reports that posted her feelings for the issue, she had felt it was a cyber crime because it involved morphing of the pictures and it was insulting and injurious to her as well as her political party’s image(See Cartoon row: Mamata loses cool, storms out of live TV session, May 18, 2012. published in http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cartoon-row-mamata-loses-cool-storms-out-of-live-tv-session-212905). Both of these crimes are recognised by the Indian Information Technology Act; the first under section 66 of the Act, which states that “If any person, dishonestly, or fraudulently, does any act referred to in section 43, he shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to two three years or with fine which may extend to five lakh rupees or with both,”( To be more detailed about this, section 43 also includes unauthorised access to computer documents and altering the document for misuse of the same, among some other types of typical computer related crimes); the second under section 66A which prescribes punishment for sending grossly offensive messages or which have menacing character, or which is false, injurious, insulting etc. Well, that is her defence, and when she expressed her defence, a battery of intellectuals and common people burst out in protest saying this is nothing but gagging the freedom of speech and expression which is, according to me, is the most coveted right enshrined in the Indian constitution. Well, that is the people’s defence. People of India have not forgotten the emergency period that was created by erstwhile prime minister Indira Gandhi in the 1970’s,  when extremely strict regulations were brought in regarding journalism and also regular right to speech. This time, the protest was stronger because Mamata herself  belongs to that generation which grew up learning what should not be done with this almost sacred right.

But still then, I stand on the opposite platform. I feel there should be a limit line in activities which keep the soul of democracy alive, namely criticising the ruling party’s decision. However, there is one ‘myth’ that anti cartoon row people believed and  I would like to break. My defence line may look very thin,  but I stand strong on that.The incidence may not have involved “morphing” of the pictures of the individuals in the true meaning of morphing. The pictures were used as it is, however, they were accompanied by set of conversations which were framed and with visual indication lines  as to from whom they are originating. Well, ask me what is morphing and how affected people feel for it, for in my capacity as a cyber victim counseller, I get to see hundreds of such pictures of women especially, and I know their pain.  

But  my defence stands on the main  ground:  usage of  the logo of a government department,i.e the Indian railways for the purpose of such cartoons, which may derogate the actual purpose of  putting up the logo in the original government website. It must be understood that the cartoons were not meant to derogate a government establishment, but criticising people in it. Unauthorised usage of government emblems for trade, business, calling and professional practices is prohibited under section 3 of The Emblems And Names (Prevention Of Improper Use) Act, 1950. If the wordings of this section are pulled broadly, probably this very cartoon row would establish another milestone in Indian legal research field; for not to forget a small observation by a wise parliamentarian Sharifuddin  Shariq, who pointed out that cartoonists are given this chance to paint the politicians “wrong”(see “We ourselves have given the chance to cartoonists”, published in The Hindu on May, 14,2012, http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article3419130.ece), which turns my attention to another question...can cartoonists fall under this law ?
People, it is wise to be a part of the largest democracy wisely. But do remember, you cannot wrongly ride over the law of the land to insult the core values of democracy.

Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2012), “Stop people: spare the disputed Mamata Banerjee cartoon”, 19hMay,2012, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”





Saturday, March 17, 2012

When women pose as men in the virtual world

http://www.cybervictims.org

Couple of years back when Laurie Drew posed as a man to befool teenager Megan, who would subsequently commit suicide, women posing as men to date with women was a very underreported and unfocussed issue. When I picked up this very  issue of women posing as men to harass women earlier in my book “Cyber crime and the Victimization of Women: Laws, Rights, and Regulations”. Hershey, PA, USA: IGI Global. ISBN: 978-1-60960-830-9 , I noticed that one of the main causes behind such behaviour for women was a burning desire to take revenge on her victim.... jealousy.....thy green eyes.... The perpetrator woman generally feels extremely satisfied when she realises that she is driving the victim woman for nothing else but utter emotional disaster. Drew posed as a boy to give Megan a feeling how unworthy she is in the eyes of a boy.....a would be man, who would subsequently approve the worthiness of a woman. Most feminist scholars have argued since long against this very apparently (un)disputed truth. But this remains a fact for a majority of women and men alike. The reason behind such a nasty game by Drew was nothing but the anger, frustration and jealousy which arose due to her own daughter’s not so friendly and comfortable relationship with Megan. 
But note that I have used “one of the main cause” to describe my reasoning behind the issue. Apart from jealousy, there is something else which also drives women to play this nasty game. Imagine when a woman poses as a man just to have fun at the cost of the emotional distress of another woman! Don’t think that such behaviours are abnormal for women; but in reality, such trend is growing.  I do get to see couple of reported cases where women, mostly younger women play this fun game. Putting on the shoes of the opposite sex and playing with other women as charming prince in dating sites and also social networking sites is no more uncommon now. I refuse to believe that this could be the result of “penis envy” only, a Freudian psychoanalysis term.  Probably this might call for deep research on cyber psychology; but something in me tells that this could also be the result of acute loneliness in the wrongdoer as well as the victim. The ‘man’ woman unknowingly falls in the self created trap when the victim woman senses something wrong with the camouflaged identity. Not to forget the trail of private investigations, police complaints and even the risk of being banned by the website itself..... the perpetrator ‘man’ woman may become a victim herself as she may invite open threats regarding her sexuality, sexual orientation and following gradual out casting by the virtual society on which she would have depended heavily to change her monotonous life.
It is high time ‘man’-woman that you go ahead with some other positive productive leisure activity, for the painful crash of your imaginary ‘flight’ to the reality-ground  may become extremely hard to cope with.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2012), “When women pose as men in the virtual world”, 18th March, 2012, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Did the court do justice to Orkut posts that reportedly called Adnan to see his end?

http://www.cybervictims.org

In the time when web censorship is getting lime light due to the recent on going tussle between the courts and the Google and other websites, the news of acquittal of four  murder accused of Adnan Patrawala pulls out  mixed response from me. In 2007, this teenager was found dead some where in Navi Mumbai. He was the son of an affluent businessman; he loved life and social networking through Orkut. He reportedly became friendly with  his alleged murderers  through Orkut (see Did Orkut friends kidnap and kill Adnan?(August 20, 2007), published in http://www.rediff.com/news/2007/aug/20adnan1.htm) and was allured by one “Angel” to go out where he  met his bloody end (See Adnan murder trial opens on Orkut;Published on  Friday, Aug 24, 2007, By Arun Ram; availbale @ http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_adnan-murder-trial-opens-on-orkut_1117311). No body knows whether he really met “angel” of Orkut or not, but the police depended heavily on the indirect evidences including the Orkut exchanges which vouched that he went out to meet some one. His family later received two calls asking for a lump sum for Adnan, who was reportedly in their custody when the calls were made. The news was leaked in the media and it created a huge wave of sympathy among Adnan’s friends who started discussing the issue in many communities. Some believe that the alleged kidnappers got panicked with the out break of the news. The media highlighted how Adnaan’s friends in Orkut have started a virtual investigation.  Resultant the wrong doers killed the teenager.  In 2012, when the alleged murderers were  acquitted, the court justified its sentencing by stating that both forensic and circumstantial evidences were “assembled so loosely that it ended up cutting down each other rather than forming a cohesive thread against the accused” (Court acquits murder accused in Mumbai teenager Adnan case, pg 20,  The Hindu on January 31, 2012). The Orkut messages between the four accused men and Adnan were considered as the “key evidences” by the police; further the police reportedly drew the conclusion that Adnan was murdered by these guys on the notion that he was last seen with one of them. The police picked up the accused on the testimony of a garment dealer who saw one of the accused lifting apparently unconscious Adnan; later on the day, when he read about the whole issue, he informed the police. The defence lawyer emphasised that “there were no eye witnesses and an identification parade did not inspire the court’s confidence”.
The question of acceptability of the exchange of messages through Orkut really presents thin chances to target the four men. This is especially so since the identity of  “Angel” remained a mystery and no one could prove that the profile was operated by any of the accused or either their aide. The case presents a tangled web in every sense. Many suspected that all the profiles may have been fake and they were made to trap the poor little rich boy. But nonetheless, the boy did fall in the trap and the whole issue, as reported in the media, created an example as how virtual friends can allure one to come out of the net and face real life danger. But the court gave more weight on the production of solid evidences rather than depending on evidences such as these. True, the court stuck to the principles of rule of law, where flimsy evidences do not find any space. Perhaps the court did the right thing on not depending too much on the Orkut messages especially when the police themselves did not go for a stringent thorough   search. The news reports suggested that the police relied mainly on the  person who saw the boy was being lifted in the car. He didn’t see the act of strangling; neither could he hear what Adnan had to say about this.  The other way round, many may shift the blame on the victim as why did he trust Angel, who was probably a fake identity; and this is probably the reason that the court didn’t want to reply upon the circumstantial evidences that came up from  the Orkut message exchanges. What did the profile owners do? They made the victim to believe them, especially Angel and come out of his home. But for what?  Every individual has right to express and simultaneously every individual has his/her own right to reciprocate or not to reciprocate to the subjects expressed by the other. But that can not be the point to draw up the conclusion and shift the burden as heavy as planning a murder and finally executing the same, to the creator of the message unless the proper nexus is proved.  Perhaps the court felt not to do injustice with these accused on the grounds of this principle................. perhaps not..
I really wish that further investigation takes place when the family goes for appeal  , and this question is answered. If the prosecution can really prove that there lies strong nexus between the Orkut friend’s messages and his murder (may be by someone who was/were operating the profiles), probably a new history would be created in Indian evidence law which is shifting very much towards cyber space happenings.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2012), “Did the court do justice to Orkut posts that reportedly called Adnan to see his end?”, 1st February, 2012, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”