Showing posts with label cyber crime against children. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cyber crime against children. Show all posts

Sunday, April 3, 2016

Getting a SIM card for free? Check these risks

http://www.cybervictims.org by Dr.Debarati Halder

On women’s day, 2016, I was invited by Suriyan FM Tirunelveli to share my opinion about safety of women  offline and online. It is indeed a sweet surprise for me each time I receive a call from the FM listeners who refer to the particular programmes they have listened and took keen interest to learn more about the risks involved in digital communication technology. This time I had this listener who made me to think about Free SIM cards.
 Truly speaking, even though Facebook or WhatsApp may boast of its popularity in India, it has failed to penetrate the rural sectors in India, especially with women. This was seen in our latest survey titled “Harassment via Whatsapp in urban and rural India: A baseline survey report, 2015”(see http://www.cybervictims.org/CCVCresearchreport2015.pdf) . The main reason for this is obviously lack of awareness about safety tools  and the well settled fear in the minds of women that using these platforms may necessarily land them in trouble. But does that mean that women and men including matured teens in these areas are reluctant to use  digital technology communication as a whole? Perhaps NO. Mobile telecommunication companies are rapidly penetrating in the rural areas with offers on the services and this also includes distributing Free SIMs to potential customers.  This however, attracts youngsters more than Facebook or WhatsApp because distribution of  free SIM cards may not always need proper verification of documents, if distributed by local dealers including shops.  Due to easy availability of mobile phones including camera phones at prices even below Rs. 2000 in Indian markets, people enjoy owning mobile phones, most of which may be armed with inbuilt cameras and double SIM facilities. Once one has a SIM card, it may become a matter of few more rupees to upgrade the status of handset to use it as a medium of  smart phones whereby the subscriber can use the SIM for double purposes; i.e., for mobile phone calls as well as for mobile data facility to enable him to get connected with internet, no matter whether he/she knows about netiquettes or basic internet laws.  Now, one must understand that  SIM card is not an ordinary micro-level chip that enables one to communicate with others. The full form of SIM stands for Subscriber Identity Module, which carries information about the holder of the SIM Card. In general, when a person buys a SIM card from a dealer, he/she is asked to provide identity verification proofs that are sent directly to the service provider to enable them to activate the SIM card in the name of the buyer/subscriber. The data that is thus revealed to the service provider, stays with them permanently as a private document which is not supposed to be exposed to any third party unless the law and justice machinery, especially the police and the courts demand such information under S.69 of the Information Technology Act, 2000(amended in 2008) (Powers to issue direction for interception or monitoring or decryption of any information through any computer resource) primarily.  Many a times when a distributor offers Free SIM cards, it is necessary that the distributor checks the existing ‘contracts’ with the interested subscriber. This is what happens when one wishes to get Free SIM cards from service providers like BSNL, which generally provides such Free SIM cards at Free SIM card distribution ‘Mela’ and to those who already own a landline from the same service provider.
In cases where free SIM cards are distributed by local dealers of mobile phones , talk time or data recharge services etc, there remains a risk of distributing used SIM cards for free. These may be SIMs which have been technically ‘discarded’ by their original owners, for various reasons including blocked numbers, stolen devices along with SIMs etc. Once an interested person opts for such free SIM, he may get to see several unknown contact options. There are cases where holders of FREE SIM may also receive calls from unknown numbers at odd hours; risks relating to data privacy for mails, social media accounts or even net banking may also be there. We need to understand that not every one may be aware of lodging complaint with the service providers regarding mobile phone (along with SIM) theft, leave the question of reporting the matter to the police. Similarly, there are numerous examples of how techno savvy criminals may re-fix  the technically ‘destroyed’ SIMs to distribute it in the market only to loot innocent people or make illegal profit by secret data mining targeting women and young people. Added with it, one must not forget the cyber terrorism scenario where innocent civil citizens are ‘used’ by numerous tricks including such lucrative offers of Free SIM distribution to gain vital information. Keeping these in mind, young students, especially those who have finished their 10th or 12th board exams, college freshers  and women must be cautious enough to opt for availing SIMs just to be ‘SMART’.
Let us all unite to save our society.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2016), " Getting a SIM card for free? Check these risks” 3rd April, 2016, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.in/




Thursday, August 20, 2015

Circulating child abuse videos: consider how the distributor re-victimises the victim/s

http://www.cybervictims.org by Debarati Halder
Very recently in Facebook a friend of mine posted a video of a little child being violently beaten by an adult. It may be the child’s father or uncle or any other caregiver who wanted the child to score more marks. Some days later, another friend of mine showed me the same clipping in her WhatsApp account. The later being a person well versed in law, did not circulate the clipping. Instead, as per my suggestion, reported the video to WhatsApp. But by this time millions of users of Facebook and WhatsApp would have seen the clipping. But this is not the only incidence of child abuse that may have been documented and circulated in the social media. There are umpteen numbers of video clippings and still images  of child abuse, sexual assault of children, rape videos etc that are being circulated every day in social media. The magic of internet network and social media make many such contents viral. Even if the receiver does not want to see such contents, he/she has to have a glance of such images when such images or clippings land up in his/her profile or account. Have you ever considered how these contents keep travelling time and places and what happens to those victims? One extremely important point every one must note that all contents are not for circulation always. Due to the smart use of smart phones, all of us have become ‘citizen journalists’ who document each and every noteworthy event in his/her daily life every day. These may include traffic violation cases, street children harassment cases, domestic violence cases and even terror strikes. In the last cases, the police and the army may continuously ask the civilians to switch off their mobile phones, especially not to use the mobile messaging services for circulating images as it may help the terrorists as well. For the cause of national security, the particular area may be blocked by intelligence department to receive any internet services. But in other cases, it depends much on individual perceptions as how we are taking the issues of harassment and why do we consider it worthy for circulating to our friends and then to millions of unknown strangers.  People who are capturing such images, may never know that the images/clippings may not only be stored in their own devices, but  may also be stored in other’s devices and that particular person/s may not take it as an issue of concern, but may take it as an issue of self gratification.
          Consider the latest clipping where the child was being beaten by the adult: in many families, parents do slap or hit a growing child as an ultimate measure to discipline him/her. Slowly Indian society is recognising such behaviour of the adults with the children as risky behaviour, especially when intentionally the adults beat the child to an extent to cause grave injury to his/her body. In some families young mothers of young children are over burdened, constantly harassed by the husbands or in laws for various issues including bad cooking, messy house keeping and even for satisfying the demanding husbands. May be because such young mothers need more time to cope with the  situation where they have to balance their time between their children and the family, they (the mothers) may direct their anger and frustration on the children. Nonetheless, such helpless situations of both the mother and child may be documented  by other adults or even children and subsequently these clippings may be used for court cases if in case the husband or the in laws want to prove that the mother is not capable of handling the child. Such images may even travel  in the internet and pile up comments which may prove extremely detrimental to the mother and children later. No one ever comes back  to look into reason why the adult woman had to beat the child or how she would have managed the child later. Who cares? The distributor/s may simply enjoy the  harsh comments targeting the poor woman and her child who may become a strong support to her later. But this is just an exceptional hypothesis which needs to be tested. In the same line, think of the child who is abused by elders including own family members: may be the recipients may shower sympathy to the child, but have you ever considered the mental state of the child when he/she gets to know that his/her clipping has been in that particular situation has been seen by hundreds of ‘watchers’ who can not help him in any way, but  may feel satisfied’ by thinking that sharing the clipping or commenting on the clipping may make them marked as ‘concerned people’.
          The same thing goes when one comes across any sexual abuse of children. Whether it is sexual harassment related to bad touch, or sexual molestation or even to graver offences like rape, one should prohibit oneself from circulating the images even for ‘accused finding’. This is especially true those who capture ragging scenes, sexual harassment scenes where  matured teenagers are victimised who may be joining higher classes after finishing the secondary board exams.  Remember that these young victims may get to see their own victimisation scenes in near future when they log into their Facebook pages or even open accounts with WhatsApp.  It is not enough to hide the faces of the victims alone when the whole scene of victimisation is circulated. The victims themselves may feel extremely traumatised to get back these scenes. It is for this very understanding that the Protection of Children from sexual offences Act, 2012 was strengthened with S.23 which reads as follows:
“23. (1) No person shall make any report or present comments on any child from any form of media or studio or photographic facilities without having complete and authentic information, which may have the effect of lowering his reputation or infringing upon his privacy.
(2) No reports in any media shall disclose, the identity of a child including his name, address, photograph, family details, school, neighbourhood or any other particulars which may lead to disclosure of identity of the child: Provided that for reasons to be recorded in writing, the Special Court, competent to try the case under the Act, may permit such disclosure, if in its opinion such disclosure is in the interest of the child.
(3) The publisher or owner of the media or studio or photographic facilities shall be jointly and severally liable for the acts and omissions of his employee.
(4) Any person who contravenes the provisions of sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) shall be liable to be punished with imprisonment of either description for a period which shall not be less than six months but which may extend to one year or with fine or with both”
However, all laws come with an exception clause where by certain actions that are  recognised as offence, would not be considered as an offence if done by the criminal justice machinery in particular ways laid down by the laws and for particular reasons which must pass the acid test of laws as well as the constitutional  provisions and guarantees.  POCSO Act stands as an exception especially in this regard when it comes to circulating the images for fact finding.  After WhatsApp has been recognised as an extremely popular medium to communicate with the police, the government is constantly encouraging to create welfare Apps whereby individuals can upload or download information or share information with the police. We need to note that even while availing this technology, police must use the images of the accused which should be independent from the crime scene as a whole. Police has been given this special right because they are the recognised organisation to carry on the investigation for the benefit of the victim as well as the society. Civilians should not take the role of the police in circulating of the images.
However, I have noted that even while in such circumstances; such circulation by the police may also meet accidental violation of the laws and victim’s rights. But we need to note that for this again, there are proper reporting and investigating mechanisms.  In my opinion, instead of taking up the responsibility of spreading the news about the accused by way spreading the victimisation clipping /image as a while( which actually spreads the victimisation of the child in question as well), people must consider immediately reporting the matter to the local police station or police head quarters with all evidence to show from where the images have travelled. This would definitely reduce the chances of re-victimising the victim and make the ‘reporter’ of the offensive clipping a saviour in a unique way.
Do consider.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2015), " Circulating child abuse videos: consider how the distributor re-victimises the victim/s”, 21st August, 2015 , published in http://debaraticyberspace.blogspot.com/

Thursday, October 31, 2013

The value of good talk in the electronic communication devices

http://www.cybervictims.org by Dr. Debarati Halder
In a recent workshop on cyber crime I was delighted to hear how young people use the social media in unique ways which were not known before. Interacting with the participants made me understand that people are taking social media more casually than before. Remember the advertisement of a particular mobile phone company where a lift man asks a young professional “will you be my Facebook friend”? As many researchers have pointed out, cheap access to internet has made more and more people getting into it; but there is a huge lack understanding of the netiquettes. Be it social media, email communication or sending SMSs, it has become a norm to send ‘smilies’, slang words or even apparently vulgar words when the communication involves two or more friends who catch up each other for casual chat. This trend has proved dangerous time and again. Especially when the matured teens or young adults are involved and they do not hold a back ground of erudite families, the problem becomes bigger. India has a large sect of urban slum population which uses indecent language in everyday life. Be it wife abuse, elder abuse, child abuse in the slums  or even drunken men making nuisance in public places, we do get to hear such sorts of words which prick minds of any educated individual; however,  I do agree that usage of bad words in domestic violence are not limited to slums only. Many of us strictly believe that the language used by elders has a huge impact on the children at home. Truly, I have seen many instances where children at a very young age started picking up the not so decent language trend and it did reflect in their social communication skill. When in school, such usage of the language may turn them into huge bullies; not to forget that there are several restrictions in freedom of speech that is guaranteed by our constitution and these children and young adults like their peers, may even unknowingly fall in the other side of law when they communicate in such unconstitutional language.
In the workshop I had asked several teachers whether they are aware of any bullying incidences including cyber bullying. Not many could answer and this showed how bullying still remains unrecognised in our country. While real life bullying does not get due attention, what can we think about online bullying? Many youngsters including college students do not understand that with a technology that helps in communicating need for understanding the value of ‘good talks’ is increasing. In India, an easiest way to trigger violence is to hurt one with community sentiments. I could not stop myself from alerting a matured teenager school student who was then residing in a private Home for poor students run by an  NGO adjacent to my home when I heard he was teasing somebody over phone by calling the recipient ‘neech jati’ ( people from lower cast). Probably the recipient also teased him in similar language, but what these children were unaware of was, they were slowly entering a big bad world unknowingly by constantly flouting the law which is meant to maintain decency of language. The boy probably had seen his peers or parents addressing others in similar fashion; but this proves how essential it has become to teach children the need to use good language while communicating over electronic devices. Nonetheless, with Diwali knocking at the door, many would be experimenting with their handsets and you readers be prepared to receive prank calls, obscene SMSs and drunken calls. Unless we as a society understand the value of good talks over bad talks, there would be more such communications which will destroy our piece of minds and may even instigate unknown dangers.
Stay safe.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2013), “The value of good talk ”, 31st October,,2013, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”