Sunday, May 25, 2014

Towards a wonderful informative network.............. but how safely?

http://www.cybervictims.org
For the last full month while India was swept over by Modi vs Rahul vs Kejriwals for the general election, I was over swept by the joy of getting published in British Journal of Criminology. The article “Online Victimization of Andaman Jarawa Tribal Women: An Analysis of the ‘Human Safari’ YouTube Videos (2012) and Its Effects”  (the online version can be found @ http://bjc.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2014/05/05/bjc.azu026.abstract?keytype=ref&ijkey=3XNPIViieFGse4G ) has been published in one of the most coveted journals that any researcher can ask for. While researching for this I came to realise the new born habit of people: sharing controversial images and adding their thoughts to it. It can become extremely dangerous at times and the above article speaks on this.
There had been numbers of online propagandas on who is good, who has done the right things, who is bad and how he/she is bad in the course of election campaigns this year. Numerous cartoon images were made, animated short films were made and people were asked to share and comment.  Some were noted by the respective political parties and the election commissionarate, majority of them went unnoticed. I found a new era in ‘free speech’ concept in India and I felt happy to note the liberal mindset of the people, especially the political campaigners to broaden the concept of free speech notion. But of course, there is other side of the coin as well. The recent arrest of  the Goan resident for expressing some thoughts on Prime Minister elect Narendra Modi is an example (See http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/goan-youth-likely-to-face-arrest-for-anti-modi-facebook-comments/) . As the press release says, among the provisions brought in against the accused, S.153(A) of the IPC holds the key to make it a snow ball of problems. The Section prohibits causing enmity between groups on grounds of race, religion, place of birth, language etc. What was written by the youth that attracted such provisions is not known to us to still now. But it may be understood that while it was noticed by some as ‘offensive’, some have also pointed this arrest as wrong. It now depends upon the courts to decide whether the ‘post’ should be given the ‘protected speech’ status by overruling the lower courts who had denied anticipatory bail to the youth. In our article above one of my main focus was on showcasing how racial trolling took place in the YouTube videos and how the Jarawa women were made the centre points of these trolling. As far as my knowledge goes, no one was arrested for making comments some of which had every condition to attract the above provision. It was because the question of cross border jurisdiction was involved and the perceptions hugely differed. But nonetheless, I must say creating such comments in the cyber /digital space and spreading it through numerous people (who spread it because they liked the message/their friend, friend’s friend, or distant acquaintance has posted it ) had created riots in India; remember the recent exodus of north-eastern people from southern states? Or, the one image of a man kicking the Kargil memorial which became viral and caused violence?  I am anxiously waiting for more news on the Goan case with my fingers crossed. Let us hope India’s notion about offensive speech is made more clear by the courts.

Keep peace
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2011), “Towards a wonderful network.............. but how safely
”, 25th May,2014, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/

Thursday, February 27, 2014

Beware examinees

http://www.cybervictims.org by Dr. Debarati Halder


Come the exam time, the children become more concerned about their studies... really? I have a different opinion this time. in one of my mid -seminar chats with the participants I got an opportunity to hear the experiences of  Latika Saran, Ex Director general of Police, Tamil Nadu. She told me about incidences of disturbing fellow classmates through the social media profiles by young teenagers. Her observation said, this is a new trend picked up by students to distract the fellow classmates just before the examination starts. I completely agree with her observation especially when I myself got to see several of such cases. Many schools including sophisticated elite schools now have included direct teaching methods through internet. Science, social science, maths and even linguistic subjects are also made easy through several educational software. Gone are those days when children had to be taken to  field trips  to make them understand just a fragment of a portion of an entire science syllabus. Now field trips are additional ways to make a child understand the whole problem. Computer and internet are working as extremely beneficial windows letting the students  visualise and realise everything . Students are encouraged to have their own emails and social media profiles to get connected to famous scientists, explorers, mathematicians etc through their own web pages or social media pages. This is extremely useful since these children are born in the internet era and they must learn to use the internet for good since early adolescent period. Home computers and internets may give wonderful opportunities to learn new things, solve problems together with the family. I have personally experienced this when my daughter wanted to know the meaning of a particular Hindi word; the whole family sat with her and learnt not only one word ( the meaning), but various ways to use the word constructively. But this is not ‘all is good’ scenario.
        Young girls often become completely shocked to see their “fake avatars”(I have explained the meaning of FakeAvatars in the context of online harassment in my article http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2270061) ; the shock turns into nervous breakdown when they come to know that these were created by none other than their classmates to distract them from their studies. Parents often tell me that their children are increasingly becoming adamant to open new Facebook profile or get connected to their friends through Twitter or Google Plus particularly when they get study leave before the exams. Some students prefer to share class-photographs with their friends through emails/chats after they are reportedly ‘begged’ by their friends repeatedly. Further, I have also come across cases where students get into online bullying during their study leaves. Some students told me that to come out of boredom during study leaves they take to internet games and they did come across several games which were ‘adult types’ and they did not tell their parents about it. However, the appreciable part is, they immediately restricted themselves from further going deeper into those games as they said ‘we are aware of the dangers of these’. But not everyone is smart like these kids. There are children who had severe fights with their parents on the issue of using the internet ‘all by themselves’ without any parental guidance during holidays sending the parents to panic camps ; the real world parent vs child arguments  did take off several days of the peaceful home atmosphere which hampered exam preparations for the child.
Ever thought why such incidences increase especially during study holidays? Mrs. Saran’s observation stands true with the testimony of a few parents who agreed that some children intentionally call up others to be online to distract them from their studies. How many of you readers remember the scene in 3 Idiots when “Chatur” circulates racy magazines to other hostel-mates during their exams to distract them? This silly prank-trend has an upliftment through Information/digital technology way. Apart from this, I must also say about one more incidence where medical students were caught red-handed with blue chips in the examination hall some years back and it was found that there was a big racket alluring the students to buy it; the intentional was not to empower the younger generation by availing them latest technology, but to sell answers to the right questions.
So students and parents, be aware of such trends. Internet is a way of learning now. But do not use it to destroy the positive powers.
Wish you all best of luck for your exams.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2014), “Beware examinees
”, 27th February,2014, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”





Sunday, December 15, 2013

The 377 and beyond

http://www.cybervictims.org Blog by Dr.Debarati Halder
With almost every free-thinking Indian getting shocked and surprised by the recent Supreme court decision to set aside the High court decision on the constitutionality of S.377 of the Indian penal Code, I can’t stop but share my thoughts on the issue. S. 377 is one of those penal laws created by the British rulers which has become obsolete in the eyes of the modern society, but sitting like an obstinate law due to the recent ruling of the Supreme Court of India. What does S.377 say? It actually criminalises unnatural sexual relationship and thereby touches the Lesbian ,Gay, Bisexual and Transgender community as well. I am one of those, who as a child were quite afraid of those ‘women’ who were not completely women. I grew up watching them in the trains, bus stops, roads, eateries and sometimes at weddings and family functions where (I was told) their presence was needed as a good omen. I continued to be ‘afraid’ of them till the day I met one who is one of them. That was way back in 1990’s when they used to socialise with people rarely. I knew how wonderful human being this person was and they as a group are more reliable friends than those who cheat and harass others in the name of friendship. I was particularly interested in their on-line presence. I did get to see lots of communities and groups in Orkut way back in 2008 and afterwards. When Orkut started losing its popularity, I searched them in other popular social media like the Facebook and found that they existed in several public, private as well closed groups. A fascinating fact that I would like to share is, while transgender, in many academic writings who are described as ‘cross dressers’, openly advertise about their sexual as well as physical appearance choices, many gay, lesbians and bisexuals take to internet often to secretly share their choices. Nonetheless, I did deal with online victimisation of such people who were violently bullied in  public forums as well as private chat messages. The pain is no less than that of any normal men or women suffering from adult bullying or hate messages. Why stopping with this? it has become a trend to tease a man by calling him a ‘gay’ or a woman a ‘lesbian’ and go on-line bragging about it  if a perpetrator wishes to bring huge embarrassment to his/her victim with immediate effect. I consider this as an insult to the LGBT community. It is a personal choice of sexual affiliation and no one should tag a person who has straight likings to be like one from the LGBT community may have. Similarly, LGBT community should have their own privacy and they deserve respect even if it is in an on-line presence. Constitutionality of S.377 has actually encouraged those who feel bullying LGBT community people is their right as such sorts of sexual preferences are seen as ‘wrong’ not only by a major sect of the society, but by the court itself.
Now, look at the practical scenario:
i. In Tamil Nadu, one transgender was provided government health worker’s job, another was given a home guard’s job as a ‘woman’ (See http://www.bbc.co.uk/hindi/india/2013/12/131215_transgender_home_gaurd_sr.shtml?ocid=socialflow_facebook_hindi). If S.377 is constitutional, then these ‘government appointments’ are bound to be affected.
ii. On-line groups and communities speaking about LGBT rights, often share information about each other. Many put up their profile status as bi-sexual, gay or lesbian in their Facebook profiles. Would this not be considered a ‘crime’ if the individual is an Indian national? If anyone feels this can be considered so, think of right to equality, freedom of speech and expression and of course right to personal preferences and right to life which has extended its scope to cover right to privacy.
iii.While I am an ardent supporter of S.66A of the Information Technology Act, which restricts some categories of speech in the internet, I also fear that this provision would lose its power if any one belonging to LGBT community wishes to avail it to prevent and punish those who would have hurled hate speech, death threats, sexual assaults to him/her just because his/her sexual preferences.
The practical scenario becomes graver as majority of Indian families deject adolescent children to attend sex education classes. But see the irony: many mothers love to dress up  their young male children as baby girls with ‘girlie’ gowns, fairy wings complete with lipsticks. Many mothers also prefer to dress up their baby girls in boy’s dresses with half pants, shorts , shirts and encourage them to pick up toys exclusively tagged for ‘boys’ just for a ‘photo-sake’. Well, young parents love to show off their children ‘cross dressed’ but they forget that once floated, these pictures, images or videos can stay back for a long time in the web; it can actually make the child extremely embarrassed when he/she starts using the social media and his/her friends and peers take a look at their ‘babyhood’ pictures and how their parents wanted show them off to the world. Many adult ‘cross-dressers’ did confess in many forums that they took up liking for what they are now, due to their childhood experiences. But do note that these adults are ‘net immigrants’ who have taken the internet as a part of their lives not very long ago. If the young parents are showing off their babies (who would be true netizens) in such fashion, ask yourself on whom the liability lies to show the path? If this is the legal scenario, would the parents be able to counsel their children who may go through major psychological changes due to this? Probably not.  Couple of weeks ago I heard this painful story of a co-passenger who was telling her friend how no one in her family supports her since she has become a ‘she’ from being a ‘he’ and how the possible employers ask them to leave right from the door step by seeing a ‘manly woman’. Yes, she has a boyfriend, but he meets her secretly because he does not have courage to accept a ‘former man’ as his legal partner. Online bullying of LGBT people is almost always based on these very facts which are painful realities.
There is one silver line in this dark cloud: the Supreme Court did observe that S.377 is constitutional. But at the same time, it also stated that it is open for the parliament to decide the final fate of it ( See  http://barandbench.com/comment/44159#.Uq6CStIW3g0), even though this is neither an ‘unchallenged fact’, (See http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/the-wrongness-of-deference/article5463126.ece), Law makers, please consider.  Law makers, please consider.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2013), “The 377 and beyond”, 16th December,2013, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”



Thursday, October 31, 2013

The value of good talk in the electronic communication devices

http://www.cybervictims.org by Dr. Debarati Halder
In a recent workshop on cyber crime I was delighted to hear how young people use the social media in unique ways which were not known before. Interacting with the participants made me understand that people are taking social media more casually than before. Remember the advertisement of a particular mobile phone company where a lift man asks a young professional “will you be my Facebook friend”? As many researchers have pointed out, cheap access to internet has made more and more people getting into it; but there is a huge lack understanding of the netiquettes. Be it social media, email communication or sending SMSs, it has become a norm to send ‘smilies’, slang words or even apparently vulgar words when the communication involves two or more friends who catch up each other for casual chat. This trend has proved dangerous time and again. Especially when the matured teens or young adults are involved and they do not hold a back ground of erudite families, the problem becomes bigger. India has a large sect of urban slum population which uses indecent language in everyday life. Be it wife abuse, elder abuse, child abuse in the slums  or even drunken men making nuisance in public places, we do get to hear such sorts of words which prick minds of any educated individual; however,  I do agree that usage of bad words in domestic violence are not limited to slums only. Many of us strictly believe that the language used by elders has a huge impact on the children at home. Truly, I have seen many instances where children at a very young age started picking up the not so decent language trend and it did reflect in their social communication skill. When in school, such usage of the language may turn them into huge bullies; not to forget that there are several restrictions in freedom of speech that is guaranteed by our constitution and these children and young adults like their peers, may even unknowingly fall in the other side of law when they communicate in such unconstitutional language.
In the workshop I had asked several teachers whether they are aware of any bullying incidences including cyber bullying. Not many could answer and this showed how bullying still remains unrecognised in our country. While real life bullying does not get due attention, what can we think about online bullying? Many youngsters including college students do not understand that with a technology that helps in communicating need for understanding the value of ‘good talks’ is increasing. In India, an easiest way to trigger violence is to hurt one with community sentiments. I could not stop myself from alerting a matured teenager school student who was then residing in a private Home for poor students run by an  NGO adjacent to my home when I heard he was teasing somebody over phone by calling the recipient ‘neech jati’ ( people from lower cast). Probably the recipient also teased him in similar language, but what these children were unaware of was, they were slowly entering a big bad world unknowingly by constantly flouting the law which is meant to maintain decency of language. The boy probably had seen his peers or parents addressing others in similar fashion; but this proves how essential it has become to teach children the need to use good language while communicating over electronic devices. Nonetheless, with Diwali knocking at the door, many would be experimenting with their handsets and you readers be prepared to receive prank calls, obscene SMSs and drunken calls. Unless we as a society understand the value of good talks over bad talks, there would be more such communications which will destroy our piece of minds and may even instigate unknown dangers.
Stay safe.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2013), “The value of good talk ”, 31st October,,2013, published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”







Tuesday, October 1, 2013

The positive side of social media

http://www.cybervictims.org
There have been lots of discussions on negativeness of social media. Children and women are considered as most vulnerable groups who can be targeted through social media and I completely agree with these views. But all is not always bad. Today completes exactly one month since I received my doctorate degree certificate from National Law School of India University, Bangalore on 1 st September, 2013. When my name was called by the Vice Chancellor and I marched towards the Hon’ble Chief justice of India who would be giving me the degree certificate, I realised that my time in the social media for past three years for almost 6 hours every day was not at all a wastage; for I built up my entire thesis on the social media and how it is being misused targeting women, how the laws are falling silent in front of the sharp abusive words that describe the victims in filthiest words and why  all is not well in the social media. A few principles that I followed to protect my digital identity were learnt from earlier researches, hugely read blogs and from my own experiences and these include keeping those information private which I never wanted to share with the world. I had a very bad experience of being stalked. Social media had nothing to do with it though, but keeping this in mind, i wanted to explore the social media and what i got in them was nothing but gems.
        Social media, as they promise, can bring  old friends back.  When I searched in Orkut, I got a whole lot of friends who were my best time buddies in the school. There were these two particular girls whom I never met since I was 12 years old. I got them back through Orkut and later got well connected through Facebook. We exchanged our phone numbers and talked for hours. They were not ‘fake avatars’( I coined this in my paper Halder, D. (2013). Examining the scope of Indecent representation of Women (Prevention) Act, 1986, in the light of Cyber Victimization. National Law School Journal, 11, 188-218)  They were real and I understood this when both of them shared particular incidents in the school that only we know. I got to know my seniors from the law college where I did my law under graduation course and each of them gave moral boosting to become what I am today. I searched for my classmates from the law college in the ‘groups’ and found out the whole gang after nearly 13 years of leaving the college. We still have virtual hang outs. We grew up together for five years and we were fresh from the high schools. Orkut and Facebook took me back to those golden days of young adulthood when almost all of us were running to the same dream: to wear the black gown and fight for justice. However, Facebook found us more matured when we would discuss about legal points, share our advanced knowledge and also grow our professional network. During my leisure time, I love  to watch the group behaviours in the social media. I actively participate in many group discussions and this has taught me the difference between ‘good talk’ and ‘bad talk’. I agree, if I had not experienced the ‘bad talks’, I would never had understood what are ‘good talks’. I still stay in many groups to learn many new ideologies of law. One such group proved to be extremely beneficial not only for my thesis, but also for my own understanding of practical aspects lawyering. I met some legal stalwarts and I was literally pampered by them when I wanted to clarify my doubts which arose while reading their works. Yes, Facebook brings you more close to your virtual professors and the ‘in- box’, if used properly can give you more than a ‘most sold’ book. Nonetheless, social media gave me opportunity to grow myself and read more current affairs. Believe me or not, i use Twitter to read the breaking news not only from one news channel, but from more than fifty domestic and international news channels, which are further shared by many Tweet- handles whom I religiously follow.
I am a Ph.d degree holder now and I may not apparently need to be glued to the social media anymore like before. But this addiction is for positive gain. This is especially so when one knows how and when to stop the virtual window and use the knowledge gained from it in real life.
Nonetheless, use social media for good and you may reap more than you sowed.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2013), “The positive side of social media”
October 1, 2013, published in http://debaraticyberspace.blogspot.com"  


      

Monday, July 29, 2013

5 (in)famous ways to become 'famous' in social media that one must avoid

http://www.cybervictims.org
In the last couple of weeks almost the whole of England was in labour with Kate Middleton who gave birth to the baby prince just a couple of days ago. Social media like the Twitter and Facebook were flooded with comments on this ‘trend’. The language used in these comments was noteworthy. Many news channels picked up good, bad, humorous and rebellious comments and instantly the comment makers became famous or (in)famous. While internationally “royal baby” could make an impact among the online update feeders, nationally many sensitive issues have influenced the good or badness of the social media. Be it the devastating Himalayan Tsunami, or the ill-fated marriage of Divya and Ilavarasan of Tamil Nadu, or the poisonous midday meals which killed so many school students in different parts of India, or the political situation; users of social media have used all these issues to express their own concerns. But the styles that have been adopted by some of these users motivated me to do a small research to know how some of them have got instant highlight for good or bad reasons. I list here some of the infamous ways to become famous, which a good netizens should always avoid:
1. Using harsh words to target the personal shortcomings including physical challenges of activists or political leaders or celebrities; one must understand they are also human beings and they feel pain as much as we ordinary individuals feel.
2.  Insulting the communal sentiments of others; no wonder, this may instantly trigger a riot.
3. Spreading false information and photo images; one can get huge numbers of ‘likes’ and followers. But think of the devastating consequences.
4. Trolling for unnecessary attention seeking; the troll may never understand that he/she may become a laughing stock very soon.
5. Posting awkward “selfie” pictures; while the contributor may attract huge attention either for him/herself, or for the background for which he/she put him/herself in the picture, this may finally be detrimental to the contributor if it involves breach of privacy or illegal activity especially when photography has been prohibited in that area.
        It must be remembered that internet is a way of life today. But that does not mean that usage of it should be detrimental to the society at large. A responsible netizen may get lime light for correct reason in due time. Short way to fame may not always be a good journey.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2013), “5  (in)famous ways to become famous in social media that one must avoid”, 29th   July, 2013,  published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”




Friday, June 21, 2013

A devastating Himalayan tsunami and a potentially destructive cyber connection

http://www.cybervictims.org
A week back Kedarnath temple and the surrounding area suffered a devastating natural disaster. While the ancient temple stood the test of nature’s fury, surrounding buildings, shafts and roads were washed away by the gushing water from River Mandakini. The news channels became busy to report the gravity of natural calamity, the human sufferings, the political blames and rescue operations. Some pointed out how the religious pilgrims described the scene as ‘Shiv-Tandav’, the destructing dance of the God. Being fed with stories from Shiv –mythology since my childhood, I was interested to see what has happened to the ancient temple. A search in the Google showed that while the ancient temple and sanctum sanatorium are intact, the calamity was really disastrous. Within days Facebook and YouTube got flooded with still and video images showing roads getting washed away, vehicles both heavy as well as light getting topsy-turvy in the flood water and building constructions moving away like storm wrecked boats. Some of these videos were from local and little known news channels, some were private videos. I was astonished to see the mindset of people who captured these moments. Nonetheless, many news channels were encouraging people to send them photos and  videos of the flood situation and in one way I appreciate this people’s involvement as it is not only cost effective but also it spreads the feeling of remaining connected. But on the other hand, it can prove extremely dangerous and fatal. For instance, I got to see this video where two young men were taking pictures of themselves in the flooded footsteps leading to the ferociously flowing river somewhere near Rambara, the place which was most affected by the flood. The other images that I came across showed similar instances with men, women and children clicking the devastative flood water dangerously flowing in their background. Coincidentally I was reading a BBC report on selfie pictures (see http://www.bbc.co.uk/hindi/international/2013/06/130610_social_media_ra.shtml?ocid=socialflow_facebook_hindi ) and I posted my own comments in the comment section too. Never imagined though that there would be a situation so soon which would motivate me to consider the issue.
Then there was this image of flood water almost submerging a tall statue of Lord Shiv in meditating posture, which was shown by almost all the news channels. One should note the comments posted under this very particular scene which was floated in the YouTube by numerous users including news channels themselves. Some of these have every potential to start a religious riot or vicious trolling. Not to end with this, there was this picture of human bridge made by soldiers helping stranded people to move to safer places, which has started getting viral in the Facebook. Undoubtedly the army is doing a momentous job in rescuing stranded people. But my doubt increased when I searched internet for this particular picture. It was not related to Uttarakhand flood, but with some other natural disaster somewhere else. By the time I came back to alert my friend who had got this picture in the Facebook timeline, I got to see many comments. Not to forget what happened last year with the Azad maidan riots in Mumbai and exodus of people of north eastern from South Indian cities including Bangalore and Chennai, which was directly linked to misinformation fed by YouTube videos, I put a small note to my friend regarding the authenticity of the information (related to the Uttarakhand flood) accompanying this amazing act of humanity that is depicted in that particular picture.
It must be noted that while social media can be extremely helpful in times of disasters such as this, it can be dangerously vicious especially when it is used to convey misinformation or when it sets dangerous examples of ‘selfie’ photos to the young users.
Please Note: Do not violate copyright of this blog. If you would like to use informations provided in this blog for your own assignment/writeup/project/blog/article, please cite it as “Halder D. (2013), “A devastating Himalayan tsunami and potentially destructive cyber connection”, 22nd  June, 2013,  published in http://cybervictims.blogspot.com/”